Look at the middle of the field, about 12 yards deep. One safety standing there means the middle of the field is closed (MOFC): expect Cover 1 or Cover 3. Two safeties split apart means the middle of the field is open (MOFO): Cover 2, Tampa 2, Cover 4, Cover 6 or 2-Man. Nobody deep at all is Cover 0.
Two safeties at 12 to 14 yards and outside the hashes are playing halves. Two safeties flat-footed and shallower (8 to 10 yards on this diagram, often 10 to 12 on real teams) are quarters safeties. If they do not match, one shallow and one deep, think Cover 6. The depth numbers on the left edge of the diagram are yards from the line of scrimmage.
Pressed, inside leverage, eyes on the receiver: man. Squatting at five yards, outside leverage, eyes on the quarterback: Cover 2 family. Off at seven or eight yards: a deep third or a deep quarter. Real Cover 2 corners sometimes press and jam as well, so depth and eyes tell you more than press alone. Leverage means which shoulder of the receiver the corner lines up on.
If a defender runs across the formation with him, it is man. If the defence only bumps over a step and passes him along, it is zone. This is the cheapest test an offence has, which is why you see so much motion on Sundays.
Where it lies. Safeties are the easiest players to move late, so the shell is the first thing a defence fakes: two high spinning to one, one high bailing to two, a blitz look dropping out. Corners have less room to hide because their alignment has to match the job. Motion is not proof either. Some zone teams run with motion, and some man teams swap assignments instead of chasing. Treat each key as evidence and look for two that agree.
How a play is graded. Each coverage has one or two plays that attack its weak spot. Those are complete. Others work in a tight window, and some run straight into the coverage. The grades follow textbook rules; on a real field the matchup and the pass rush decide just as much.